---
title: "Dynamic Decay Rates: Worthy Challenge or Futile Pursuit?"
description: Explore the challenges and benefits of implementing dynamic decay rates in interest rate risk management. Discover practical solutions and expert insights.
image: https://blog.plansmith.com/hubfs/data-graphs.png
---

[CALL TOLL-FREE 1-800-323-3281](https://www.plansmith.reachproductions.net/project/call-toll-free-1-800-323-3281/)

[![Plansmith](https://blog.plansmith.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Plansmith-Logo.png?width=764&height=135&name=Plansmith-Logo.png "Plansmith")](https://www4.plansmith.com)

- Solutions 
    - [Budgeting](https://www4.plansmith.com/budgeting/)
    - [ALM](https://www4.plansmith.com/alm) 
          - [ALM Advisory Services](https://www4.plansmith.com/alm/advisory-services/)
    - [CECL](https://www4.plansmith.com/cecl/)
    - [Strategy](https://www4.plansmith.com/strategy/) 
          - [Market Intelligence](https://www4.plansmith.com/market-intelligence/)
- Products 
    - [StrategyGPS](https://www4.plansmith.com/strategygps/)
    - [Compass](https://www4.plansmith.com/compass/)
    - [BankersGPS](https://www4.plansmith.com/bankersgps/)
- Resources 
    - [Blog](https://blog.plansmith.com/)
    - [Videos](https://plansmith.wistia.com/projects/7qemazkqii)
    - [Compass Tutorials](https://info.plansmith.com/compass-tutorials)
    - [Lunch N’ Learn](https://info.plansmith.com/lunch-n-learns)
    - [Webinars](https://www4.plansmith.com/webinars/)
    - [About](https://www4.plansmith.com/about/)
- [Schedule A Discovery Call](https://www4.plansmith.com/contact-us/)
- [CALL TOLL-FREE 1-800-323-3281](tel:8003233281)

# Plansmith Blog

# Dynamic Decay Rates: Worthy Challenge or Futile Pursuit?

Posted by [Dave Wicklund](https://blog.plansmith.com/author/dave-wicklund) on 1/2/26 10:01 AM

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

Over the past several years, the banking industry has seen seismic shifts in deposits as trillions of dollars in Government stimulus were released into the economy, followed by a period of dramatic increases in market rates which then resulted in massive amounts of low yielding balances migrating into higher-paying CDs and non-bank investment products. Now, as deposit rates have begun to fall, we're seeing depositors look for higher yields both inside and outside the banking industry.

As we all know, the movement of funds experienced by the industry has not only taken a toll on earnings, but it has left us, and examiners, questioning the *stability* of those remaining deposit balances. That deposit stability is also a key factor/assumption in interest rate risk modeling. The assumption is commonly referred to as a “decay rate,” and those assumptions are primarily intended to capture the natural attrition of deposit account customers over time.

Given the importance of these assumptions, we’ve started to see some examiners suggest that decay rates should not be “static” across all model shock scenarios, but, rather, vary based on other factors such as mergers, competition, alternative investments, reputation, and general economic conditions.

The upside is that we can pretty quickly refute that idea for factors such as mergers, competition, and reputation, since we’re supposed to be modeling interest rate risk, and those items have nothing to do with interest rate movements. However, “economic conditions” and “alternative investments,” arguably can be related to movements in market rates (i.e., interest rate risk).

Unfortunately, that then opens up a whole other set of questions/challenges surrounding making assumptions about how decay rates should change (be made dynamic) for an infinite number of possible rate scenarios stemming from those changing economic conditions and what other alternate investments might be available in the market.  

At the most basic level, one could argue for using dynamic decay rates in parallel shock scenarios (like we typically do for loan or MBS prepayment speeds), but for those of us that actually then have to do those studies, I’d ask, *“how do you do that?”* There are so many different ways to do a decay study, and getting good historical data can be a significant challenge, so how do you actually do the math and come to any meaningful conclusions? Even though we’ve just lived through a relatively extreme rate cycle of massive rate increases, now followed by falling rates, and any given financial institution could look at their own changes in non-maturity deposits (NMD) levels in that environment, how do you account for all of the factors that likely impacted that actual customer behavior; most significantly, did the institution raise their NMD rates to keep deposits, what was the institution paying on CDs, and what CD (or even MMDA) specials were available in the market (or even online nationwide)? The simple answer is, “you can make a qualitative adjustment to the math,” but that would then have to be supportable as well.

And even if we get to some meaningful dynamic decay assumption for rising rates, what about the falling rate environment that appears to still be in process? We could look back to the previous market decrease in 2020/2021, but that time period was clearly abnormal because of trillions of dollars in stimulus cash being dumped into the economy. Beyond that, most financial institutions won’t be able to go back to the last falling rate environment of 2007/2008 and get meaningful data at the customer account level to do a good study. Moreover, even if you’ve come up with different decay rates for all of the rising and falling rate scenarios, what kind of adjustments would be made for all the possible non-parallel shock scenarios?

It's certainly fair to entertain the idea of dynamic decay rates, and good arguments can be made that they aren’t static in all rate environments, but, in reality, the hurdles of getting good data, using an applicable methodology, and making realistic and supportable qualitative adjustments are high enough as it is. I’ve seen so many bad studies over the years, that I have very little faith that you’d end up with anything that is truly predictive. In the end, you just end up making up numbers and hoping that it satisfies your examiners and auditors.

So, that’s enough negativity. What’s the answer? I think you continue to push for good standard decay studies that are well documented and regularly updated, and then be sure that those decay rates (and other key model assumptions) are subject to rigorous and regular sensitivity testing. Institutions should also be sure to conduct alternate scenario modeling when considering material strategic initiative and/or changes to their balance sheets are expected to occur. At a minimum, all institutions should run a stress or alternate scenario at least once a year where they materially shorten their decay rates so they at least realize what the impact would be on EVE if, for any reason, their NMDs become significantly less stable.

If you need help with decay studies, deposit trend reviews, or sensitivity testing,  reach out to us. We can take a look at some options to be sure that your IRR management program not only meets regulatory expectations, but also helps you better manage risk and plan for changing market rate environments.

Give us a call or email us at [advisory@plansmith.com](mailto:advisory@plansmith.com) to discuss your organization's individual needs.

 

![Wicklund Head Shot 1-1](https://blog.plansmith.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Wicklund%20Head%20Shot%201-1.jpg?width=109&height=136&name=Wicklund%20Head%20Shot%201-1.jpg)Dave Wicklund  
*Director of ALM Advisory Services*

 

 

 Topics: [interest rate risk management](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/interest-rate-risk-management), [IRR](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/irr), [asset liability management](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/asset-liability-management), [decay rate](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/decay-rate), [deposit trends](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/deposit-trends), [IRR Assumptions](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/irr-assumptions)

### Subscribe Now!

### Posts by Tag

- [community bank planning (52)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-planning)
- [community bank strategy (52)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-strategy)
- [community bank (49)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank)
- [community bank budget software (45)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-budget-software)
- [credit union planning (44)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/credit-union-planning)
- [community bank budgeting (42)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-budgeting)
- [budgeting (39)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/budgeting)
- [interest rate risk (35)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/interest-rate-risk)
- [community bank interest rate risk (33)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-interest-rate-risk)
- [community bank budget (30)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-budget)
- [strategic planning (28)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/strategic-planning)
- [asset liability management (27)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/asset-liability-management)
- [interest rate risk management (27)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/interest-rate-risk-management)
- [community bank marketing strategy (26)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-marketing-strategy)
- [fintech (26)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/fintech)
- [community bank ALCO (25)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-alco)
- [social media for community banks (24)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/social-media-for-community-banks)
- [strategy (24)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/strategy)
- [IRR (22)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/irr)
- [bank strategy (21)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/bank-strategy)
- [social media (20)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/social-media)
- [strategic thinking (20)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/strategic-thinking)
- [ALCO (19)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/alco)
- [community bank forecasting (17)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-forecasting)
- [strategic planning for banks (17)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/strategic-planning-for-banks)
- [ceo (16)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/ceo)
- [Strategic Plan (12)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/strategic-plan)
- [bank strategic planning software (12)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/bank-strategic-planning-software)
- [community bank planning software (12)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/community-bank-planning-software)
- [leadership (12)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/leadership)
- [CECL (11)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/cecl)
- [Customer Service (9)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/customer-service)
- [playbook (9)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/playbook)
- [alm (8)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/alm)
- [bank budget (8)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/bank-budget)
- [bank irr reporting (8)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/bank-irr-reporting)
- [liquidity (8)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/liquidity)
- [credit union interest rate risk (7)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/credit-union-interest-rate-risk)
- [crisis planning (7)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/crisis-planning)
- [forecasting (7)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/forecasting)
- [budget playbook (6)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/budget-playbook)
- [compass (6)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/compass)
- [Outsource IRR (5)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/outsource-irr)
- [banker education (5)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/banker-education)
- [surge deposits (5)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/surge-deposits)
- [bank mission vision core values (4)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/bank-mission-vision-core-values)
- [continuing education (4)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/continuing-education)
- [credit union budgeting (4)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/credit-union-budgeting)
- [millennials (4)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/millennials)
- [reforecasting (4)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/reforecasting)
- [IRR Assumptions (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/irr-assumptions)
- [board training (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/board-training)
- [branch budgeting (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/branch-budgeting)
- [decay rate (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/decay-rate)
- [millennial employees in banking (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/millennial-employees-in-banking)
- [rising rates (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/rising-rates)
- [what-ifs (3)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/what-ifs)
- [AI (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/ai)
- [FDIC (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/fdic)
- [backtesting (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/backtesting)
- [bank brand marketing (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/bank-brand-marketing)
- [board of directors (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/board-of-directors)
- [compliance (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/compliance)
- [cost center budgeting (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/cost-center-budgeting)
- [deposit study (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/deposit-study)
- [deposit trends (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/deposit-trends)
- [funds transfer pricing (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/funds-transfer-pricing)
- [market intelligence (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/market-intelligence)
- [millennials in banking (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/millennials-in-banking)
- [modern human resources strategy for banks (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/modern-human-resources-strategy-for-banks)
- [peer analysis (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/peer-analysis)
- [stress testing (2)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/stress-testing)
- [Insider (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/insider)
- [asset prepayments (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/asset-prepayments)
- [baby boomers (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/baby-boomers)
- [brand (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/brand)
- [client spotlight (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/client-spotlight)
- [contingency funding plan (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/contingency-funding-plan)
- [credit union strategic planning software (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/credit-union-strategic-planning-software)
- [employee human resources for banks (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/employee-human-resources-for-banks)
- [event (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/event)
- [financial institution succession planning (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/financial-institution-succession-planning)
- [funding (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/funding)
- [loan prepayments (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/loan-prepayments)
- [market analysis (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/market-analysis)
- [negative rates (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/negative-rates)
- [policy (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/policy)
- [ppp loans (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/ppp-loans)
- [profitability (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/profitability)
- [sensitivity testing (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/sensitivity-testing)
- [social video for banks (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/social-video-for-banks)
- [strategic action plan (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/strategic-action-plan)
- [trade show (1)](https://blog.plansmith.com/topic/trade-show)

See all

### Recent Posts

- Navigate 
    - [Home](https://www4.plansmith.com/)
    - [Budgeting](https://www4.plansmith.com/budgeting/)
    - [Asset Liability Management](https://www4.plansmith.com/alm/)
    - [CECL](https://www4.plansmith.com/cecl/)
    - [Strategy](https://www4.plansmith.com/strategy/)
    - [Market Intelligence](https://www4.plansmith.com/market-intelligence/)
    - [About](https://www4.plansmith.com/about/)
    - [Contact Us](https://www4.plansmith.com/contact-us/)
- Products 
    - [StrategyGPS](https://www4.plansmith.com/strategygps/)
    - [Compass](https://www4.plansmith.com/compass/)
    - [BankersGPS](https://www4.plansmith.com/bankersgps/)
- Resources 
    - [Blog](https://blog.plansmith.com)
    - [Videos](https://plansmith.wistia.com/projects/7qemazkqii)
    - [Compass Tutorials](https://info.plansmith.com/compass-tutorials)
    - [Lunch n' Learns](https://info.plansmith.com/lunch-n-learns)
    - [Webinars](https://www4.plansmith.com/webinars/)

#### Contact

1827 Walden Office Square, Ste. 350  
Schaumburg IL 60173

Toll Free: 1.800.323.3281  
Local: 1.847.359.4045  
Fax: 1.847.705.8200

info@plansmith.com

Copyright 2018 | Plansmith Corporation

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Dave Wicklund",
    "url" : "https://blog.plansmith.com/author/dave-wicklund"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-01-02T16:01:59.946Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-01-02T16:01:59.000Z",
  "headline" : "Dynamic Decay Rates: Worthy Challenge or Futile Pursuit?",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.plansmith.com/hubfs/data-graphs.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.plansmith.com/dynamic-decay-rates-worthy-challenge-futile-pursuit",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.plansmith.com/hubfs/Plansmith-Logo-Budgeting-ALM-Outsourcing-01.png"
    },
    "name" : "Plansmith"
  }
}
```